Search Site

Injury from Swinging Gate Found to be Work-Related

After receiving denials from the New York state retirement board, a hearing officer, and the state comptroller, a New York State employee has finally been determined to have sustained an injury making her eligible for disability retirement benefits, based on an incident which occurred in June of 2010.

The benefits applicant, Sheila Traxler, was working as a corrections officer at the time of the accident. Traxler had brought a group of three inmates into a clothes room, which was protected with a gate that automatically swung closed when released. Traxler was then called by someone outside the room, causing her to turn around and open the gate to see who had called her. When doing so, one of the inmates opened the gate to walk out of the clothes room. Traxler heard the gate and turned around, calling for the inmate to stop and return to the room. The inmate nevertheless continued walking out, releasing the gate and causing it to swing back and strike Traxler. She sustained injuries to her neck, back, and shoulders when the gate hit her, and also now suffers from chronic headaches.

Traxler applied for performance of duty disability retirement benefits, alleging permanent incapacitation resulting from the incident. Her application was denied initially, as well as by a Hearing Officer who considered her request for redetermination. The Hearing Officer stated that the reason for the denial was that Traxler had failed to establish that her injuries were the result of the act of an inmate. However, the Appellate Division disagreed, and found that Traxler’s injuries qualified as the type of injury that would entitle Traxler to performance of duty disability retirement benefits. The court explained that, In order to qualify for disability retirement benefits under New York Retirement and Social Security law, Traxler was required to show that her injuries were “the natural and proximate result of any act of any inmate.” Courts have repeatedly held that the petitioner is required to prove that “his or her injuries were caused by direct interaction with an inmate.” The court found in Traxler’s case that, while the inmate may not have intended to cause the gate to strike Traxler and cause her injury, there was no question that it was the disobedient act of the inmate in ignoring Traxler’s command that she remain in the room, and in doing so releasing the gate, that caused Traxler’s injuries. The court ordered that Traxler’s case now proceed to consideration on the issue of whether her injuries are permanent.

If you are a disabled or injured worker in New York and need legal help obtaining the benefits to which you believe you’re entitled, contact Highland workers’ compensation and disability retirement attorney Peter M. Cordovano for a consultation, at 845-691-4200.

Contact us

Please fill out the form below and our attorney will contact you.

Quick Contact Form

Our Office
  • Highland Office
    1 N Roberts Road
    Highland, New York 12528
    Phone: 845-691-4200
  • Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent Peer Review Rating Badge showing Peter M. Cordovano is rated AV Preeminent
  • Client Champion Silver 2021
  • Avvo Rating Badge showing Peter M. Cordovano is rated a 9.0 Top Attorney
  • New York State Trial Lawyers Association Logo
  • Manhattan College
  • Touro Law College logo
  • Top Lawyers Peer Recognition
  • "I thank you for your attention to this matter I have received a first payment today for a two week period allotment, my notification to you via voice-mail was to keep you informed of my status. You have been excellent in all matters pertaining to my case, and I feel I'm in good hands. I’ll keep in communication in updates as I'm sure PMA will as well God Bless ..."  -–Darren P.

  • "I would like to thank you, for all you have do for me and my son. You are the most kind person and excellent lawyer I known in my life. You are our angel. For us, the way the things happened was a miracle, after all our sorrow."  -–Maria Izquierdo

  • "Peter, you can go ahead and start paperwork. I know it’s not a fair settlement, but I’m drowning. Don’t know what else to do Thank you for everything you’ve done for me. I really do appreciate you."  -–Valerie S

  • "I hope that this letter finds you in good spirits and in excellent health. I know we’ve had our difficult moments (usually due to my constant need for reassurance from you). But there isn’t a day that I don’t thank God for your levelheadedness and perseverance. Thank you."  -–Eileen

  • "Dear Peter, We can’t thank you enough for all of your help! We appreciate it more than you know! Thanks."  -–Rick, Debbie & Ricky

  • "I would like to thank you for all you have done for me and my family. You’re the best!"  -–A. Chambers

  • "Many thanks for your donation to our 2nd Annual Huskies 5K Challenge. The event was a tremendous success due in large to your generous support."  -–HMS PTA

  • "Thank you for sponsoring me to play on the Dutchess Debs. I am having lots of fun and learning a lot. I look forward to the upcoming spring season."  -–Jordan C.

  • "We are so tardy thanking you so please know we are so grateful for your time with us, prep phone calls to Bob Lackaye and follow up work on behalf of Spencer. We are resting with her anxiety about moving forward and pushing Spencer out to be a part of the workforce and world again. Believe me we are so thankful for the many miracles since the accident on July 12, 2014! Thank you for meeting us and assessing Spencer and his needs in such a caring and professional way. Your staff was friendly, caring and supportive the entire time we were in touch with your office. Many thanks for your time! Blessings to you all!"  -–D.E

  • "Dear Peter, Thank you so very much for your thoughtful and beautiful plant. Believe it or not, it will join the one you sent 5 years ago which has developed into many others too!!"  -–Fondly, Deb & Jo